In the early years of school, some children stand out. They seem to learn to read with ease, have a quick grasp of math, and demonstrate a polished classroom performance. They earn praise, high grades, and are seen as “ahead.” It’s a promising start.
Yet, educators and developmental psychologists know that early academic ease doesn’t always translate into long-term learning resilience. The cognitive demands of school evolve. Education becomes less about acquiring foundational skills and more about managing abstraction, ambiguity, complexity, and change.
The learners who appeared to “have it all figured out” in the first few years of elementary school, may very well be the ones who feel most destabilized later.
This isn’t a paradox—it’s a predictable developmental shift.
When “Smart” Stops Being Simple
Young students labeled capable or even "gifted" often come to define themselves by how easily they can succeed. When this achievement becomes their identity, experiences requiring more effort are uncomfortable, even threatening. Over time, this can lead to patterns that get in the way of long-term growth:
- Avoiding challenge to preserve the appearance of ease
- Fearing mistakes because they seem incompatible with being “smart”
- Struggling with perfectionism and rigid thinking
- Plateauing when tasks demand more mental effort than they've practiced using
It’s not that these students lack potential—but they may lack the cognitive capacity and emotional scaffolding to handle the kind of learning that gets harder before it gets better.
The Changing Nature of Learning
In early school years, some students excel because the environment happens to match their natural strengths. They may have strong capacities in some foundational cognitive functions: visual memory, phonetic awareness, sense of number. But as they progress into middle and high school, learning begins to require more:
- Executive function – juggling competing demands and organizing thought
- Cognitive flexibility – shifting approaches and adapting to new information
- Metacognition – reflecting on how one learns, not just what
- Emotional regulation – managing stress, uncertainty, and social comparison
To be clear, these are not academic skills—they are cognitive functions. And these days, when knowledge is rapidly evolving and future careers increasingly demand innovation, collaboration, and resilience, these cognitive and emotional capacities become just as vital as early talent.
Read more about cognitive functions here.
Read more about 21st-century learning here.
The Gifted Paradox
It can be easy to assume that high-achieving students don’t need extra support. But students who’ve never had to struggle often don’t learn how to respond to it when it inevitably arrives. This is the paradox of giftedness: the very ease that defines early success can leave students less prepared to cope when ease disappears.
Fortunately, researchers and educators are increasingly emphasizing the value of helping all students—not just those who are behind—develop a robust, flexible cognitive profile. This fosters learning across all stages of development.
Looking Ahead: Cognitive Readiness in a Complex World
As the future becomes more unpredictable—technologically, socially, environmentally—academic content alone won’t be enough. Students will need to learn how to learn, adapt, unlearn, and relearn. This means securing the underlying brain systems that support critical thinking, problem-solving, focus, and emotional endurance.
Some educational approaches, including cognitive enhancement programs like Arrowsmith, are designed to support this development explicitly. Structured and intentional training that has a clear goal: to prepare learners not just to perform, but to persist, adapt, and grow.
A Call for Awareness
Giftedness and achievement in the first years of school doesn’t diminish a child’s strengths. It enriches our understanding of what they’ll need next. Early success should be celebrated, but not mistaken for the end of the developmental journey.
When the conversation expands from performance to potential, from talent to adaptability, children are equipped not just for school—but for life in a complex and ever-changing world.
.svg){kind=small}
